Craving a cookie that’s way bigger and better than the rest? At Holy Cow That’s a Big Cookie, we bake some of the largest and most delicious cookies in Rochester, NY—and ship them nationwide! Whether you’re ordering for yourself, sending a sweet surprise, or planning a fundraiser, our massive 6-inch cookies are made from scratch with premium ingredients and baked fresh to order.

Sprinkle Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Candy Chip Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Sugar Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Double Chocolate Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Over the Moon Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Candy Explosion Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Candy Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Chanilla Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Chocolate Candy Explosion

Starting at $5.00

Peanut Butter Cookie

Starting at $5.00

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

Starting at $5.00

5 Pack Mix-N-Match

Starting at $25.00

Shop Fresh-Baked Cookies from Rochester, NY

Browse our full selection of classic flavors like Candy Chip, Double Chocolate, Peanut Butter Explosion, and Sprinkle, or check out our seasonal specials, decadent brownies, and rich cakes. You can even build your own custom cookie box for the ultimate treat.

Order online today and discover why Holy Cow Big Cookies are quickly becoming a favorite across Western NY and beyond.

You can order Holy Cow Big Cookies online with complete confidence through our secured online shopping cart, or get in touch with our staff for special inquires, fundraisers and custom orders.

We can be reached by phone at 585-392-1870 or via email through our contact page.