Free shipping for 8 or more cookies

Order Online Order Online
Red circle with a white phone handset and signal waves, indicating a call or phone icon. (585) 392-1870
White Facebook f logo inside a solid red circle on a transparent background. Red circle with a white Instagram camera logo in the center.
Black shopping cart icon on a white background. [0]
Order Online Order Online
Red circle with a white phone handset and signal waves, indicating a call or phone icon. (585) 392-1870
0
  1. Home
  2. Custom Cookies

Freshly Baked Custom Cookies for Every Event

Celebrate life’s sweetest moments with custom cookies from Holy Cow That’s a Big Cookie. Whether you’re planning a birthday party, wedding, baby shower, or simply want to make your next gathering unforgettable, our artisan cookies bring flavor, fun, and originality to the table. Each cookie is baked fresh with care and decorated to match your theme, making them the perfect treat for any occasion in Rochester, Buffalo, Syracuse, and beyond.

Browse our most popular custom cookie designs below—or contact us to create something completely one-of-a-kind.

Birthday Cookies

Celebrate any age in style! Our custom birthday cookies are colorful, delicious, and guaranteed to be a guest favorite.

Baby Shower Cookies

Add a sweet surprise to your celebration with baby shower cookies that are as adorable as they are tasty.

Graduation Cookies

Honor your graduate with custom cookies that are artistic, memorable, and just as special as their big achievement.

Engagement Party Cookies

Say congratulations in the most delicious way possible—our custom engagement cookies are perfect for sharing the love.

Wedding Cookies

From receptions and rehearsal dinners to bridal showers, our custom wedding cookies make every moment sweeter.

Sports Cookies

Game day just got better. Our sports-themed cookies are the ultimate win for tailgates, team parties, and fans of all ages.

Holiday Cookies

Spread the cheer with festive holiday cookies that taste as good as they look—perfect for family gatherings and office parties.

At Holy Cow That’s a Big Cookie, our team of skilled bakers puts creativity and craftsmanship into every batch. From intricate designs to bold flavors, we’ll help you create cookies that look amazing and taste even better.

Ready to order your custom cookies? Call us today at 585-392-1870 or reach out through our contact page to get started.

You can order Holy Cow Big Cookies online with complete confidence through our secured online shopping cart, or get in touch with our staff for special inquires, fundraisers and custom orders.

We can be reached by phone at 585-392-1870 or via email through our contact page.

© 2025 Holy Cow! That’s a BIG cookie. All rights reserved.