Free shipping for 8 or more cookies

Order Online Order Online
Red circle with a white phone handset and signal waves, indicating a call or phone icon. (585) 392-1870
White Facebook f logo inside a solid red circle on a transparent background. Red circle with a white Instagram camera logo in the center.
Black shopping cart icon on a white background. [0]
Order Online Order Online
Red circle with a white phone handset and signal waves, indicating a call or phone icon. (585) 392-1870
0
  1. Home
  2. Shop Online
  3. Peanut Butter Cookie

Peanut Butter Cookie

Peanut Butter Cookie

Brand: Holy Cow Cookies

$5.00

FULFILLMENT OPTIONS

This item can be shipped

Local Delivery Opening Hours

Sunday - Saturday: Open all day

We've said it before, and we'll say it again; peanut butter makes EVERYTHING better. Our peanut butter cookie is yet another take on a classic, only we took it one step further making it huge and packing it full of more smooth, creamy peanut butter than ever before.

Related Products

5 Pack Mix-N-Match

5 Pack Mix-N-Match

Starting at $25.00
Double Chocolate Brownie with Chocolate Chips

Double Chocolate Brownie with Chocolate Chips

Starting at $5.00
Candy Chip Cookie

Candy Chip Cookie

Starting at $5.00
Candy Cookie

Candy Cookie

Starting at $5.00
Over the Moon Cookie

Over the Moon Cookie

Starting at $5.00
Candy Explosion Cookie

Candy Explosion Cookie

Starting at $5.00
Chocolate Candy Explosion

Chocolate Candy Explosion

Starting at $5.00
4-Layer Cookie Cake

4-Layer Cookie Cake

$29.00

You can order Holy Cow Big Cookies online with complete confidence through our secured online shopping cart, or get in touch with our staff for special inquires, fundraisers and custom orders.

We can be reached by phone at 585-392-1870 or via email through our contact page.

© 2025 Holy Cow! That’s a BIG cookie. All rights reserved.